I'm very tired and irrtated with this community
Jul 31, 2023 18:47:46 GMT
MantleM, Snood, and 2 more like this
Post by ziggycashmere on Jul 31, 2023 18:47:46 GMT
I have always believed, and will continue to do so, that everyone should be allowed to search for whatever they want without anger or shame placed on their search. I've said before in other threads that if I wasn't searching for X topic, I wouldn't be contributing to something else instead. I'm only looking for that X topic because it's something I want to find.
With that said, I also believe to some extent, that older people from the community have created an idealized image of what it used to be simply because it was smaller and the requests for cartoon or kids stuff weren't as noticeable.
However, if you look back at the first 10 articles that were ever posted to the site, which yes I did make a video on, all of them are either
-based on kids properties (Wicked Witch, Rule Removal)
-NSFL (Armin Meiwes, Grizzly Man Audio)
-or have that spooky feel (Ringu Brussels Cut)
These are pretty much the three big categories that most people say they have an issue with but they've been popular since the beginning. Not to mention, I can remember the days of the SpongeBob Albanian dub and other topics that were considered stupid at the time. Every era of the community has certainly had its share of topics that nobody cared about.
I also disagree with the idea that we're wasting time searching for topics that aren't really lost like pilots. This actually goes back to a bigger discussion that I've seen on Twitter before about what really counts as lost media but realistically, if we eliminated every piece of lost media that by definition, someone had or was never intended to be seen, all we'd have left are really old stuff like movies from the 1920s and dubs that people would still be complaining about.
I've probably said this before too and I don't think it's really a controversial opinion, but the reason why nobody wants to search for old books or movies is because there is little appeal to them compared to a SpongeBob commercial. And I guess that's part of the issue raised, the complaints that there isn't enough interest in historical media but it goes back to what I said at the beginning, people are going to search for what they are interested in. It's that attachment and personally connection to something that makes someone care about it.
One could argue that the community would be better off without that nostalgic attachment but I don't see it like that. I don't feel like it's the community's responsibility to archive historical works simply because "they matter more". Without the passion that people give to the topics they're interested in, the community as a whole would have never grown. It probably would have gotten abandoned at some point or died out completely during the move from the Wikia site to this one.
"With that said, I also believe to some extent, that older people from the community have created an idealized image of what it used to be simply because it was smaller and the requests for cartoon or kids stuff weren't as noticeable."
This, I think, may be a hole I myself have fallen in. Kids media I'll agree has always been popular here but I remember it being far less popular back then than it is now, and I guess that's because it was way smaller back then. I do remember creepy and NSFL media getting the biggest spotlight even back then, but at least those were things that seemed to have a far bigger scope and were a little deeper (and a little older). The last time I've seen something even similar to that happen was with Hitogata, but I understand this is something that just sort of happens.
Though in my personal opinion NSFL media shouldn't even really be something sought for, but that's another conversation.
"And I guess that's part of the issue raised, the complaints that there isn't enough interest in historical media but it goes back to what I said at the beginning, people are going to search for what they are interested in. It's that attachment and personally connection to something that makes someone care about it."
This I understand and have said before that you should only look for things you're actually interested in seeing, so I agree. I just find it strange that there seems to be a severe lack in people searching for things that they don't have a nostalgic connection to or at this point even looking for something over 25 years old. Nearly everything I've searched for and had interest in I didn't have a nostalgic or personal connection to, and I thought that used to be common, but maybe I'm misremembering?