Lost Spongebob Squarepants Baseball Lecture "Animation"

The part that's throwing me off is the mention of Mr. Incredible because in theory that would mean it wasn't a Nickelodeon exclusive license and might have been unofficial. It probably wouldn't have been too much for an in house team to use existing assets and make the characters say stuff about baseball.

However I did find something else that's pretty interesting- this CGI baseball character named Scooter.



I'm only pointing it out because this character appeared in broadcasts during the 2004 season and Tom Kenny did his voice. There could be some kind of connection here if they rehired Tom for a SpongeBob animation a year later.

Well OP says that they only heard about The Incredibles one and that they doubt it's true, so really we only have a shaky connection to The Incredibles one existing.

As for the Tom Kenny connection, I dunno if you saw but I did mention that Tom Kenny had a bumper on Nickelodeon where he was demonstrating how to the Spongebob voice but used various takes of him singing "Take me to the ball game" which seemed like a weird choice? I know the only connection here is Tom Kenny and that song being a baseball classic, but could it have been for this official thing? Especially since it seems Nickelodeon has some kind of working relationship with the MLB for a game to be made, and for there to be a Nickelodeon night? What we should look at is how the video game came about, maybe we'll get insight in how long the two partnered for, since both the game and Nickelodeon night are pretty recent.

That is true. I haven't considered this possibility, but could either the Spongebob or Incredibles one be mandala effect? I don't think the Spongebob one is, but the Incredibles one may be so.

Intersting. So we know the Nick license goes back to at least 2011. I will see if I can find anything else

I looked for The Incredibles one. Found nothing. Maybe the Happy Meal commercial played on a Jumbotron, but that is all. 

youtu.be/Kl-V46dr1d8

Here's a complimation. I don't think so though, he does a different sounding voice.

Mr. Incredible aside, the strangest thing to me is the fact that OP claims SpongeBob was explaining how to have fun- which was probably like one of those speeches kids hear about playing fair and stuff.

This would mean it's not connected to Scooter describing different pitches and Tom Kenny singing that song for the commercial but something completely different. I know my theory of it being unofficial doesn't really have any evidence but it makes me think that based on what OP has described so far.

Hopefully he'll come back and confirm or deny some of our speculation.