Sometimes I like to play the most random songs I can find beyond what I normally listen to and yesterday, I was listening to a bunch of random songs I came across this one, "The Carmack Song" from the album "Music of the Alaska-Klondike Gold Rush" I could swear the melody sounds familiar to me and its from another piece of music like a folk song, waltz or something but I can't quite put my finger on what it is. Does anyone know if the melody is from another piece of music and if so, what it is?
A lot of those songs were in the public domain and sometimes used as back tracks for shows and cartoons. Maybe you can start by listening to popular songs from around that time period.
We know that it's a folksong. Whether it has the same or a similar melody as another folksong is a different matter.
If you can find a physical copy of the album or its book version, it might have liner notes with more information. If you can read music, you could also look at other fakebooks for similar tunes.
I swore I wrote a reply to this yesterday but it was either deleted or I forgot to hit reply. what I wanted to say was that it's most likely not a folk song. Instead if it was an older tune it was probably an instrumental or written to be performed by a singer. This song might have a lot of rhythm/melody patterns similar to traditional American folk songs like I've been working on the railroad, but has too many notes outside of the scale and large jumps (especially one that's an octave and a half between why and I). Folk songs usually only use easier to remember and sing intervals like 2nds - 6ths. They also usually only have 5-6 different notes, but this song has 9. This seems much more like a song that would have been practiced before being sung and not something that people would just sing for fun/while they worked/mined gold.
I found this song recently and I was reminded of the Carmack song! I think Spancill Hill might be the familiar song you were thinking of. It's not exactly the same, it's more like a minor version. www.youtube.com/watch?v=yndityNBbJs
I found this song recently and I was reminded of the Carmack song! I think Spancill Hill might be the familiar song you were thinking of. It's not exactly the same, it's more like a minor version. www.youtube.com/watch?v=yndityNBbJs
I know that song well and have heard a number of different versions, and while it does kind of remind me of the Carmack song, that isn't it.
I saw this clip and heard this song in some documentary about apples and I was like wait is this the Carmack song? (somehow I'm still thinking about it): www.youtube.com/watch?v=V_IrdS-zu48
Sometimes I like to play the most random songs I can find beyond what I normally listen to and yesterday, I was listening to a bunch of random songs I came across this one, "The Carmack Song" from the album "Music of the Alaska-Klondike Gold Rush" I could swear the melody sounds familiar to me and its from another piece of music like a folk song, waltz or something but I can't quite put my finger on what it is. Does anyone know if the melody is from another piece of music and if so, what it is?
I was instantly reminded of the childrens' song "Where, Oh Where Has My Little Dog Gone?" Linking the following video simply because the animation is hilariously terrible:
I did a little digging into where this song came from, and found that it was written in 1864 by a composer name Septimus Winner (which is a hell of a name), who got inspiration for the tune to that song from this German folk song, titled "In Lauterbach hab i mein Strumpf verlorn," written in 1827:
Is it possible either one of these songs was the one you were trying to think of as the similar tunes?
I know you're only talking to keep the silence out Maybe you should listen and leave some room for doubt You're just handing out bad reputations Why don't you shut your mouth? -Motorhead, "Overnight Sensation"
Sometimes I like to play the most random songs I can find beyond what I normally listen to and yesterday, I was listening to a bunch of random songs I came across this one, "The Carmack Song" from the album "Music of the Alaska-Klondike Gold Rush" I could swear the melody sounds familiar to me and its from another piece of music like a folk song, waltz or something but I can't quite put my finger on what it is. Does anyone know if the melody is from another piece of music and if so, what it is?
I was instantly reminded of the childrens' song "Where, Oh Where Has My Little Dog Gone?" Linking the following video simply because the animation is hilariously terrible:
I did a little digging into where this song came from, and found that it was written in 1864 by a composer name Septimus Winner (which is a hell of a name), who got inspiration for the tune to that song from this German folk song, titled "In Lauterbach hab i mein Strumpf verlorn," written in 1827:
Is it possible either one of these songs was the one you were trying to think of as the similar tunes?
It does sound similar to "Where, Oh Where Has My Little Dog Gone?" and that might be what I was thinking off, I am still not sure. That could be it, but I also get a melody of some fast Country/Bluegrass tune come into my head that sounds a bit similar to this only faster but I have been unable to find out what it is yet. If I have time, I'll see if I can play the tune I am remembering on my keyboard and post that.
You are right about that animation being bad. Haha. I have not heard that German song before, but I did know Septimus Winner's name as I came across it on my searches. What a name.