Post by nostalgist32x on May 19, 2024 21:12:54 GMT
It says that "Nearly Witches (Demo)" is found even though it was only a 1 minute snippet featured on the CitizensFOB compilation. Any other longer version on YouTube is fanmade & is spliced with the final (trust me I checked.) Could someone fix this?
It says that "Nearly Witches (Demo)" is found even though it was only a 1 minute snippet featured on the CitizensFOB compilation. Any other longer version on YouTube is fanmade & is spliced with the final (trust me I checked.) Could someone fix this?
It says that "Nearly Witches (Demo)" is found even though it was only a 1 minute snippet featured on the CitizensFOB compilation. Any other longer version on YouTube is fanmade & is spliced with the final (trust me I checked.) Could someone fix this?
No I'm talking about farther down beside the box that says nearly witches
did you not see where it is found? If it's not on the thing it said then it's lost but if it is on the thing it said and then just no body has put it online doesn't mean it's lost. It just means someone needs to track down the thing it's in.
No I'm talking about farther down beside the box that says nearly witches
did you not see where it is found? If it's not on the thing it said then it's lost but if it is on the thing it said and then just no body has put it online doesn't mean it's lost. It just means someone needs to track down the thing it's in.
I found the CitizensFOB mixtape and it only had the 58 seconds.
did you not see where it is found? If it's not on the thing it said then it's lost but if it is on the thing it said and then just no body has put it online doesn't mean it's lost. It just means someone needs to track down the thing it's in.
I found the CitizensFOB mixtape and it only had the 58 seconds.
Maybe but 1 minute is really short for a song and it starts and ends abruptly.
it's a mixtape. Those can happen and it happens on a lot of mixtapes. Mixtapes are the roughest releases of all the versions out there.
EDIT: Discogs confirms it's 58 seconds and it's a demo and most demos are shorter then the actual song if one actually comes out. Some times they are longer than the actual song, but that's rare, and sometimes demos don't even become a full song.
Maybe but 1 minute is really short for a song and it starts and ends abruptly.
it's a mixtape. Those can happen and it happens on a lot of mixtapes. Mixtapes are the roughest releases of all the versions out there.
EDIT: Discogs confirms it's 58 seconds and it's a demo and most demos are shorter then the actual song if one actually comes out. Some times they are longer than the actual song, but that's rare, and sometimes demos don't even become a full song.
I guess that's possible but most of Panics! Demos are always the full length song. Also the discogs listing doesn't mean anything because they're just listing how long it was on the mixtape, they wouldn't list the full length even if they did know it because that'd be inaccurate.
it's a mixtape. Those can happen and it happens on a lot of mixtapes. Mixtapes are the roughest releases of all the versions out there.
EDIT: Discogs confirms it's 58 seconds and it's a demo and most demos are shorter then the actual song if one actually comes out. Some times they are longer than the actual song, but that's rare, and sometimes demos don't even become a full song.
I guess that's possible but most of Panics! Demos are always the full length song. Also the discogs listing doesn't mean anything because they're just listing how long it was on the mixtape, they wouldn't list the full length even if they did know it because that'd be inaccurate.
I was saying that Discogs says the accurate length for the version on the mixtape which is the version that is listed on the wiki for the only known version to exist. Which means the version on the wiki is correct and doesn't need to be changed from found to partial until there is knowledge that a longer version exists
I guess that's possible but most of Panics! Demos are always the full length song. Also the discogs listing doesn't mean anything because they're just listing how long it was on the mixtape, they wouldn't list the full length even if they did know it because that'd be inaccurate.
I was saying that Discogs says the accurate length for the version on the mixtape which is the version that is listed on the wiki for the only known version to exist. Which means the version on the wiki is correct and doesn't need to be changed from found to partial until there is knowledge that a longer version exists
That exactly what I was saying too. I'm just saying it shouldn't be used to determine if we have the full version or not because unless whoever made it had some type of inside access they'd never know if it's the complete version. They're just listing what is shown on the release.
I was saying that Discogs says the accurate length for the version on the mixtape which is the version that is listed on the wiki for the only known version to exist. Which means the version on the wiki is correct and doesn't need to be changed from found to partial until there is knowledge that a longer version exists
That exactly what I was saying too. I'm just saying it shouldn't be used to determine if we have the full version or not because unless whoever made it had some type of inside access they'd never know if it's the complete version. They're just listing what is shown on the release.
It never said full version or otherwise. I believe that wether it a partial song or a full song either it being demo or not should still count as being found if it's the only version available and known. That's what I am saying.