What is your “I didn’t care for The Godfather.”

Even when I was watching that show on my grandmothers house on CN and Boomerang I don't remember ever being all that impressed by it. I liked the more modern movies like On the Rocks and Flintstones Meet the Jetsons but i feel like the original show was mostly remembered for being the first animated show aimed at adults(well that and the ads for Winston Cigarettes)but if you look past that it does not really hold up, same with The Jetsons(I prefer the 80s version of that show myself).

The Simpsons and Family Guy aren't the only ones. I was really into Robot Chicken as a kid and I stopped caring for it around 2008-09. I loved American Dad in the late 2000s and early 2010s but haven't really followed it since 2013. I was a South Park nut from 2008 to about 2013 but that phase has ended. My love for Aqua Teen Hunger Force started in the early 00s and continued much longer but that eventually wore off. If this counts as an adult cartoon, I was also really into Total Drama for a while and briefly got back to it again in 2018 but moved on.

So yeah, I get burned out from adult cartoons lol.

Glad you brought up Robot Chicken because I honestly really never got into that show aside from a few random sketches, for me sitting through an entire episode was a challenge as for every sketch that worked there were like five others that just failed miserably so I found it more enjoyable to just watch the actually funny ones on Youtube(I.E. Mario in GTA, the Toy Story one with Andy in college, the Sonic one, etc)and ignore the rest. Hell I would've never even known that show existed if Family Guy hadn't referenced it multiple times.

I think American Dad has actually gotten even better since you stopped following it so i'd recommend getting back in(wish we'd get a premiere date for the new season already, especially since it looks like it's going to be the last one with TBS not doing anymore scripted stuff).

Aqua Teen Hunger Force was a show I could never get into, the random humor just never landed for me and I just found myself bored by it and the characters.

Total Drama was OK for me but I kinda lost interest after the first season and didn't really keep up with the show after that. 

I never really got that much into the major sketch comedy shows like SNL or MadTV personally, I preferred stuff like "The State", "Short Circuitz" and "Key and Peele".

Part of me wonders if "younger, developing brains" (especially children's brains) are just naturally more accepting of more repetitive media. Like as an adult, I can easily pick up on overused tropes, overused characters, overused dialogue, variations on the same plot over and over, etc. But you are still "learning" as you grow up into your 20s and consume more and more media, so you can simply be more comfortable with watching the same thing over and over as you process it. 

The only thing I have ever seen on command from that show is the "Weird Al" Weasel Stomping Day music video. Other than that, I hate the show.

I also do genuinely hate PewDiePie as a person, me not liking his content has nothing to do with that though